koth_trainyard_a1
99 Comments
 
33/0/67 Round Win % (6 rounds) (Click for more information)

Trainyard

by Unknown

Feedback

Avatar Total Rapscallion left feedback: October 2022
also helps with sightlines
Avatar Total Rapscallion made an annotation at 1822 -1472 -440 while standing at 2135 -1566 -372 October 2022
try playing around with the elevation of the ground ! TF2 maps generally aren't flat, it makes for boring gameplay
Avatar The -- Jorolap left feedback: October 2022
if you are a first mapper and want to work with lights use hammer++ and select the 3dview text and you can compile lights
Avatar Total Rapscallion made an annotation at -920 -2086 16 while standing at 2529 -2093 9 October 2022
this upper area is very barren, it would be interesting to have some geometry around here
Avatar arcticcu made an annotation at 2289 -3826 -436 while standing at 2438 -3876 -379 October 2022
what's the purpose of this empty space here
Avatar arcticcu made an annotation at -394 -2787 -443 while standing at -558 -3248 -379 October 2022
this area has nothing interesting, perhaps some props?
Avatar Craftosaur left feedback: October 2022
skybox is too low
Avatar arcticcu made an annotation at 106 -1499 -439 while standing at 107 -1245 -379 October 2022
this sightline = bad
Avatar Brokkhouse left feedback: October 2022
consider showing this map in #wip on the tf2maps channel before testing, a lot of the feedback here does not require a test
Avatar Total Rapscallion made an annotation at 188 -4252 -364 while standing at 270 -477 -372 October 2022
sightlines that go accross the entirety of the map are generally to be avoided
Avatar [UHG]barracks obimbo left feedback: October 2022
block more sightlines
Avatar arcticcu made an annotation at 1110 -2069 -82 while standing at 1340 -2218 -21 October 2022
need something here to make fighting fun
Avatar The Announcer made an annotation at 312 -2175 121 while standing at -68 -2171 -21 October 2022
the ceiling is too low. Signed - Soldier.
Avatar arcticcu made an annotation at 1502 -2022 -82 while standing at 1732 -2172 -21 October 2022
top too barren
Avatar Wilson left feedback: October 2022
There is no real way to salvage this layout without just rebuilding it from scratch because it is just a big box.
Avatar Yellow Dice made an annotation at 1181 -4229 -372 while standing at 731 -4229 -372 October 2022
did not even block spawn doors come on now
Avatar Ten_Tacles made an annotation at 1035 -3874 -358 while standing at 2386 -2352 -21 October 2022
You can spawncamp from up here
Avatar The Announcer made an annotation at -454 -3858 -431 while standing at -550 -3904 -372 October 2022
Might want to make this area a bit smaller or more interesting.
Avatar Wilson left feedback: October 2022
and areas.
Avatar Wilson left feedback: October 2022
This is definetely a map you should take as a learning experience, look at some official koth layouts, try having more map
Avatar Kash Patel left feedback: October 2022
in general sources of light are too strong
Avatar Wilson left feedback: October 2022
This is going to cause a lot of sightline and spawn camping issues because there is no map between anything.
Avatar Kash Patel left feedback: October 2022
roof too bright, making me go blind
Avatar the sneeze of 87 left feedback: October 2022
mark the cap zone somehow, e.g. caution tape texture
Avatar Hadull left feedback: October 2022
please learn the very basics on map making before you start to make a map
Avatar Wilson left feedback: October 2022
This whole map is just a big box with some props and a bridge with nothing between spawns or areas.
Avatar CHICKEN GREMLIN left feedback: October 2022
Try making the name something a little more unique next time
Avatar CHICKEN GREMLIN left feedback: October 2022
The filename is too generic - it can (and likely will) cause 'Map differs from server's' error. (1/2)
Avatar Craftosaur left feedback: October 2022
gaps above the spawn doors you can shoot grenades into
Avatar arcticcu left feedback: October 2022
the skybox is super low
Avatar Hadull left feedback: October 2022
no gameplay ever takes place on a flat plane
Avatar Wilson left feedback: October 2022
You are bound to cause map conflicts with people with a lot of maps.
Avatar Wilson left feedback: October 2022
You want to avoid generic names like Warehouse, Trainyard, etc. There are countless A1s of them over the years.
Avatar [UHG]barracks obimbo made an annotation at 1083 -3941 -391 while standing at 1076 -4051 -379 October 2022
i run into this spawndoor a lil bit cause its not fast enough/trigger isnt big enough
Avatar Ten_Tacles made an annotation at 2462 -609 -414 while standing at 2095 -521 -379 October 2022
What is this room?
Avatar Craftosaur made an annotation at 1193 -4003 -382 while standing at 1192 -4008 -382 October 2022
gap above the spawn door
Avatar Hadull left feedback: October 2022
gm_flatgrass
Avatar Official 7 Eleven made an annotation at -253 178 -6 while standing at -359 184 65 April 2020
i can't imagine your supposed to be able to stand on this block here
Avatar Gruppy made an annotation at 586 -3248 -63 while standing at 581 -3252 -59 April 2020
make door frames non soldi
Avatar Yoshark made an annotation at -156 418 25 while standing at -202 563 66 April 2020
clip this
Avatar Switchgeer made an annotation at 678 1047 132 while standing at 691 1076 156 April 2020
these stairs aren't clipped
Avatar Yoshark made an annotation at 137 3374 -118 while standing at -47 3308 -59 April 2020
fix doors
Avatar scrly left feedback: March 2020
underground route doesnt seem effective
Avatar TheFluffycart made an annotation at 484 -3251 -62 while standing at 484 -3392 -62 March 2020
The sewers are really close to the point, and serve little purpose in my opinion
Avatar Don Donovan "The Don" Donatello made an annotation at 567 -1080 -78 while standing at 625 -1105 -27 March 2020
that pickuptip
Avatar Don Donovan "The Don" Donatello left feedback: March 2020
need a patch overlay under these pickups
Avatar Official 7 Eleven left feedback: March 2020
mid feels really cramped, maybe space out the train cars
Avatar scrly made an annotation at 611 -906 -61 while standing at 706 -1172 -47 March 2020
why is this a ramp?
Avatar Neon Tango left feedback: March 2020
red texture on blue side
Avatar scrly left feedback: March 2020
some texture choices are weird
Avatar scrly left feedback: March 2020
point could use hazard tape to show cap zone
Avatar aaaaaaa made an annotation at 760 1815 -101 while standing at 798 1833 -52 March 2020
this
Avatar Otter | Free The Sea left feedback: March 2020
not a long of ammo near the point
Avatar TheFluffycart made an annotation at 494 3186 -66 while standing at 646 3124 -62 March 2020
Door's are broken
Avatar TheFluffycart made an annotation at -449 2354 74 while standing at -475 2350 81 March 2020
Yo, why can I stand here?
Avatar Humphrey Chimpden Earwicker made an annotation at -457 2380 -95 while standing at -440 2449 81 March 2020
weird clipping platform here
Avatar Sarijinn made an annotation at 781 -58 5 while standing at 1105 -262 68 March 2020
mark capture zone better plz
Avatar TheFluffycart made an annotation at 717 975 33 while standing at 322 917 -2 March 2020
Why is this so tall?
Avatar Yoshark made an annotation at 379 -1025 118 while standing at 604 -949 226 March 2020
don't use these props for stairs, use brushwork instead
Avatar Neon Tango made an annotation at 939 -1430 -92 while standing at 504 -1483 -52 March 2020
make this one building
Avatar DR VLAD CRAZY made an annotation at 416 -3251 -59 while standing at 416 -3520 -59 March 2020
keep the underground area
Avatar i3green left feedback: March 2020
I feel like the cap area should be larger
Avatar maksu made an annotation at 269 1565 -89 while standing at -206 -1049 267 March 2020
lmao i can snipe people here and they can't do much about it
Avatar ])oo]v[ made an annotation at 1067 -885 -56 while standing at 1283 -1365 -4 March 2020
kinda want a stack of crates or something here so its not just a flat open space
Avatar Neon Tango left feedback: March 2020
this ma would beinfi alot from displacments
Avatar Neon Tango made an annotation at 772 1565 -90 while standing at 805 1357 -52 March 2020
make this wider
Avatar Spleep left feedback: March 2020
make the capzone bigger
Avatar ])oo]v[ made an annotation at 796 287 2 while standing at 1083 -554 68 March 2020
hazard stripes make me think the whole middle is the cap area
Avatar Spleep made an annotation at 485 126 -204 while standing at 435 -125 -166 March 2020
the underground area doesnt seem that useful
Avatar MI6zombieguy92 made an annotation at 330 765 -23 while standing at 688 1011 211 March 2020
this rooms seems ominous
Avatar ::Egan:: left feedback: November 2014
at the moment, that is. you can make it better
Avatar Teddy Schnapps left feedback: November 2014
I didn't even know how to get to the point for the longest time
Avatar ::Egan:: left feedback: November 2014
map is also pretty confusing just in general
Avatar Teddy Schnapps left feedback: November 2014
the map is nice but makes team work almost impossable
Avatar ::Egan:: left feedback: November 2014
feel really seperated from my team, no big team battle for point
Avatar The Announcer left feedback: November 2014
love the general feel of the map
Avatar Teddy Schnapps made an annotation at -123 2495 -471 while standing at 109 2043 -347 November 2014
below is soo out of the way
Avatar 1999 left feedback: November 2014
A bit too Engie friendly
Avatar 1999 left feedback: November 2014
Too easy for the other team to reach each other's spawns
Avatar Teddy Schnapps made an annotation at -383 1871 -472 while standing at -40 1448 -347 November 2014
down here is very dark, hard to see players
Avatar Teddy Schnapps left feedback: November 2014
this map has good cover and passage ways but it's way to cramped, it needs more open areas for action
Avatar Pocket left feedback: November 2014
I wish there were any real significance or need for the underground area, but there doesn't seem to be
Avatar Yellow made an annotation at -169 1270 -368 while standing at -88 1367 -350 November 2014
downstairs is a beautiful area, but no reason to go down there
Avatar Pocket made an annotation at -574 735 -104 while standing at -624 733 -59 November 2014
Shouldn't you be using the wide-gauge track here?
Avatar Teddy Schnapps made an annotation at -333 902 -233 while standing at -248 1015 -123 November 2014
lol, wtf is this?
Avatar Teddy Schnapps made an annotation at 244 743 -79 while standing at 280 749 -59 November 2014
if you're going to player clip an area you should make it clear players can get somewhere
Avatar Teddy Schnapps made an annotation at 949 953 -121 while standing at 847 667 -59 November 2014
might want to put a fence of something to show players you can't get by this train
Avatar norfolk left feedback: November 2014
walls should be team colored, not the ground
Avatar Teddy Schnapps made an annotation at 429 -194 -14 while standing at 438 -199 -27 November 2014
you might want to make the door here "notsolid" so players don't get stuck
Avatar The Announcer made an annotation at -245 -765 150 while standing at -237 -608 148 November 2014
love this supply closet
Avatar The Announcer left feedback: November 2014
great signage
Avatar Teddy Schnapps made an annotation at -229 -268 104 while standing at -78 -138 132 November 2014
also, what is the point of this large pillar in middle of spawn? it surves no purpose
Avatar The Announcer made an annotation at -350 929 -176 while standing at -140 888 -235 November 2014
this is a big no no
Avatar norfolk made an annotation at -606 2959 -95 while standing at -636 3024 -59 November 2014
Tracks lead to NOWHERE
Avatar Yellow left feedback: November 2014
very confusing layout
Avatar Teddy Schnapps made an annotation at -314 -386 168 while standing at -279 -585 148 November 2014
spawn room seems way too dark, unless that's the theme
Avatar Teddy Schnapps made an annotation at -309 -765 138 while standing at -316 -708 148 November 2014
um, why did you make the resupply locker barried almost completely inside the wall?
Avatar 1999 made an annotation at 462 3292 -260 while standing at 363 3303 -235 November 2014
why is this ramp so tiny
Avatar norfolk made an annotation at 444 4960 136 while standing at 544 4752 145 November 2014
Looks weird